On the table is a decades-old unsolved murder case. As clever investigators, the task is to reexamine this cold case and solve the case. How well is Thinkfun’s Cold Case board game done and does it captivate us?
June 1988: Murder of investigative journalist Andy Bailey. In front of us is a thick file of witness statements, evidence, photos and a letter as an introduction to this Cold Case. As big fans of Bosch, the series about the taciturn genius detective who just can’t let go of old cold cases and who regularly throws himself into the bullet fire with full commitment to solve them, we were immensely looking forward to this case from Thinkfun, the game publisher known for its crisp puzzles.
Does the game create a whodunit atmosphere and does it succeed to captivate us? Is the case easy to solve and does it address beginners or advanced players? How tricky is the case and is the solution comprehensible and coherent?
After Escape Games dominated the market as puzzle games in the last years, more and more interesting crime games for home are coming out at the moment. In the style of the adventure crime dinners, there are also crime dinners for the home, for which you usually have to be at least six people and play the role of the suspects yourself. The largely depends on how much effort you put into dressing up and embodying the role and playing it.
In the Cold Case board game A Story to Die For, on the other hand, you can expect a crime game without preparation, without disguises, which you simply open and start playing and it can also be played alone.
Note: Thinkfun, or rather the Ravensburger Spieleverlag to which Thinkfun belongs, kindly provided us with a review copy of the Cold Case board game A Story to Die For. However, this review is unpaid and reflects our honest opinion.
In the box there are the files. It consists of letters, lists, witness statements, autopsy report, photos and other clues.
On the Thinkfun homepage you can play an intro video to start the game. There is no predefined gameplay. As in a real case, the objective is to meticulously look through the file and come to conclusions. The goal of the game is to answer four open questions on the homepage about the murderer, the murder weapon, the possibility of escape and the stolen money.
Whether the results of the investigation are correct is then checked on the homepage, where you also get hints on how to solve them. Once all the questions are solved correctly, we learn the background to the murder and the Cold Case board game A Story to Die For is successfully solved and over.
Files with coffee stains, quality material. The Cold Case board game basically consists of a file with a lot of reading material, which is beautifully crafted and fit into the 80s in the presentation. We were four investigators, two of whom let out a sigh of relief at the prospect of having to work through 24 pages of paper. For this game, all players should in any case have a desire to read, because this is how you spend a large part of the game time. It would have been nice to have the option of playing back written documents such as the witness statements in an app in order to delve deeper into the case – this is done particularly well and atmospherically in the new Audio Mystery games from Ravensburger, for example.
The enclosed additional clues can be quickly classified after a brief look and the chain of clues also quickly takes shape. It is quite classic to pay attention to motive, means and opportunity and to search the file for them. Overall, the case is easy to solve and the Cold Case board game takes about 1.5 hours, most of which is spent reading and listening. The shared fun of the game is mainly in sharing trains of thought, combining the clues together until a conclusive chain of evidence emerges.
It’s a pity that at least a small interaction on the homepage wasn’t built into the case, since you need the homepage to play anyway or the one or other surprise is waiting for you. A creative or surprising idea would have done us good, since we are spoiled by the competition in this respect.
The price is very fair. For little money you get with the Cold Case board game A Story to Die For a game designed with attention to detail to enter the world of crime games with a sure sense of achievement.
The Cold Case board game A Story to Die For is a good introduction to the crime game genre with an almost certain sense of achievement. Regarding the difficulty level, it is rather aimed at beginners with the obvious clues of the evidence.
Experienced investigators and seasoned puzzle game professionals, whose hearts beat faster with complex combination tasks and tricky puzzles like in the EXIT games for advanced players, should be through with the solutions in about 20 minutes and miss the lack of creative thought work.
The first Cold Case baord game offers atmospheric evidence, designed with attention to detail. Recommended as an introduction for new investigators to the crime game genre and beginners with a sure sense of accomplishment, but for experienced investigators on the hunt for complex cases with convoluted clues and quandaries, this is the right crime game.
Your grey cells love new challenges? Then it’s worth taking a look at our board game tips! On Abenteuer Freundschaft there are also many special ideas for activities with friends, as a couple and with the family to discover. It’s worth browsing!
*This post contains affiliate links. This means that if a product (e.g. on amazon) is ordered through it, we receive a small commission without changing anything for the buyer on the price.
Abstract art is hilarious? Bullshit?!? In the Artbox drawing game, you often find yourself laughing and shaking your head, and you're happy as a lark when the points start hailing in.
Break in until you break out! In this galactic exit game for the home, you have to penetrate deep into the forbidden zone. And in 3D! Alien encounters included...
Harkuna is an open game world in which you can develop your character and experience numerous different adventures. Ideal for gamebook beginners!
Are you a policeman, a shark hunter, an oceanographer or even Jaws? In this game, players slip into the roles of the famous blockbuster. The outcome is uncertain!
Almost everyone has broken a sweat playing City Country River. At the same time, the game is an absolute classic, which is still fun even if you play it for the 1000th time. Nevertheless, we felt like a change and have come up with 3 new variants. Find out more here!
There are rarely games that do something completely new, Dixit does just that! You can find out why we were immediately enthusiastic about the board game here in the review.